“I don’t believe in
an interventionist God
But I know darling
that you do
But if I did I
would kneel down and ask him
Not to intervene
when it came to you
Not to touch a hair
on your head
To leave you as you
are
And if he felt he
had to direct you
To direct you into
my arms.” (Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds “Into my Arms”)
These are the opening lines of the most touching song about love. It
starts with God, or rather – not believing in him. To be more precise – not
believing in a certain “variant” of God, widely assumed to be true: a God who
intervenes in the world he has created.
To me, this is a troubling idea: a God existing somewhere
beyond our world, giving us the
so-called “free will” but deciding to step in and amend/demolish things from
time to time. When things have gone wrong, when we have gone too far, when we
need to be disciplined or rewarded – or simply, when we have prayed sincerely
enough.
I always wondered as a child: does God listen to all my prayers? So if I want someone
else to fail, and I pray sincerely, will he actually fail?
-
No child,
- a priest would reply – God only listens
to the prayers which are in line with his will.
Back then, this reply seemed reasonable enough. But I
have my doubts now: if it’s in line with his will, why pray at all? It would
have happened anyway. Or would God be quite absent-minded, and not noticing
that some things, that are in line with his will, haven’t been looked after
yet? Would God have moments like “Oh yes, that little girl, she needs to get
all the volumes of “Anne of Green Gables” under the Christmas tree, I totally
forgot”!
I never got all the volumes in one go, but getting them
one by one (which wasn’t easy, as the times were communist, and the supply of
books was limited) was even better. Was that God’s will? Does God care at all
about such details? Or was it pure coincidence? The fact is – I did pray.
Now I don’t think prayers work in this way. I’d rather be
inclined to think that if you really want something with all your heart, and
that thing really is a good thing –
it probably will happen. It might
have to do with fields or waves that your thoughts might be producing (I’m not
sure about how it works in practice, but I have a hunch that physicists will
one day discover that). Whether you are a believer or not. Whether you end your
thoughts with a solemn “Amen” or not. I believe that good thoughts have very
strong executive power, as opposed to some omnipotent God, sitting in a safe
place outside of our world and watching us try and fail.
That wouldn’t be a loving God at all. If he watched us,
and decided to intervene from time to time, that would mean he didn’t love us
enough. A free will, guaranteed from time to time only, isn’t free will at all.
Anyway, I don’t think he is a HE at all. I’m sure all
religious beliefs are to be taken more metaphorically than not. I love
metaphors, so I have no problems living next to them. But metaphors they remain…
they make it easier for some to get closer to understanding the divine, but
unfortunately also easier for some Cartesian minds to completely dismiss them
as relics of the past.
Willigis Jäger, the most inspiring monk and
author I ever came across describes it like this: “God manifests himself in a
tree as a tree, in an ant – as an ant and in you – as you. But in none of those
creatures does he manifest himself completely. He has infinite potential”. As the world, with all its good and evil, is
a manifestation of God, it doesn’t need any intervention from a superior
power. It’s perfect the way it is.
I believe that God’s love is absolute: it lets us err and
fail if we choose to, it doesn’t punish us if we do wrong, it and gives us
hope and strength to get up. It lets us deny its existence and doesn’t insist
on worshipping it. Not touching a hair
on our head, leaving us as we are. Because as we are – this is how we’re
supposed to be. Divine.